Realtor.com has been poring over the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2025 American Community Survey. In a report on Monday, the website revealed intriguing insights into the growing phenomenon of homeowners who have no mortgages.
And it is a growing phenomenon. Last year, 41% of homeowners nationwide were unburdened by a mortgage. In 2010, only 32.8% were mortgage-free.
That’s a big change in 15 years. But, as is usual with housing markets, the experience can be very different depending on where one lives.
State and Metro Variations
More than half (56.6%) of homeowners owned their properties free and clear in West Virginia last year, the state with the highest proportion of mortgage-free proprietors.
At the other end of the spectrum, in the District of Columbia, only 26.5% of homeowners were in that happy position. As a metro, too, Washington, DC had the highest incidence of mortgages.
Miami is the metro with the lowest incidence, with only just over half (54.1%) of homeowners paying a mortgage.
Age and Being Mortgage-Free
Some expect a retirement destination to have a greater proportion of older people who have paid off their mortgages.
However, it’s not the straight line one might expect. Mortgage-free homeownership among those aged 75 years or higher is declining.
Last year, 28.7% of homeowners in that age range still had a mortgage, compared with 20.3% in 2010. So, retired folk are either more comfortable living with a mortgage at an advanced age or are finding themselves with no choice in the matter.
Looking at the 50 largest metros, one’s least likely to find a homeowner in this age bracket with a mortgage in Grand Rapids, MI, and most likely in Riverside, CA.
Mortgage Freedom = Freedom of Movement
The average rate for a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage was 2.65% on Jan. 6, 2021, according to Freddie Mac, an all-time low. That same rate was 7.11% last Thursday.
It didn’t go above 4% between May 2019 and March 2022. That was nearly three years when homeowners could refinance their mortgages to exceptionally low rates. And, unsurprisingly, almost everyone who could did.
“Some 20% of homeowners today own a rate lower than 3%, and it’s easy to see why they don’t want to give it up by selling,” wrote Bloomberg in September.
“On a $400,000 home, the difference between a 3% mortgage rate and a 7% mortgage rate could mean nearly $1,000 per month and $350,000 in interest over the life of the loan, depending on the down payment,” Bloomberg continued.
The Mortgage Rate Trap
No wonder this has come to be known as the “mortgage rate trap.” Who would move at such a huge financial cost unless they absolutely had to?
Of course, those who have no mortgage pay no mortgage rate. So, they’re not trapped. They can move as freely as ever.
“Mortgage rates have been a central constraint on the housing market, and rate changes affect markets differently depending not only on how the mortgage rates that current homeowners pay differ from the market, but also on how much of the housing stock is financed,” wrote Realtor.com in its data analysis.
“Areas where owners rely more heavily on mortgages are more sensitive to rate changes, because monthly payments and the cost of moving both rise with borrowing costs,” continued the analysis. “Areas with a higher share of outright ownership are less exposed and may feel smaller effects from rate shocks because residents who own their homes outright are likely indifferent to changes in borrowing costs.”
Unfortunately, Realtor.com goes on to warn of the likelihood of further hikes in general interest rates by the Federal Reserve, which, through a knock-on effect on mortgage rates, means “the lock-in effect is likely to tighten the market again.”
Why the Geographical Differences in Mortgage-Free Homeownership?
We already mentioned the high (if decreasing) rate of mortgage-free homeowners among older people, who are often attracted to areas such as Florida, which are popular among retirees.
But other factors probably affect the overall rate. For example, people who move often reset the clock on their 30-year mortgage, extending the period over which they will have a home loan.
“In 2024, just 11.2% of U.S. households relocated, the lowest mobility rate since the Census Bureau began tracking the measure in 1948,” reported ABC 17 News in August. “That works out to about 14.8 million households changing addresses, which is a fraction of the movement seen even a decade ago.”
At least some of that is likely down to the mortgage rate trap. But the report continued: “The trend isn’t universal across the country, however. In West Virginia and Pennsylvania, households spend well over a decade in the same home.”
So, it may be no coincidence that West Virginian homeowners are the least likely to have mortgages. They reset their mortgage clocks less often.
But there is likely another component. It’s easier to pay off a mortgage on a lower-value home than a higher-value one.
And West Virginia was the state with the second-lowest home prices in the country in May 2026, with a median price across all home types of $253,300, according to World Population Review.
Meanwhile, California and Washington, DC, where many homeowners have mortgages, came first and third in those home price rankings with $854,000 and $676,500 respectively.
And, of course, there may be cultural differences. In places like DC and Silicon Valley, people are often highly career driven, moving jobs and homes frequently to chase job opportunities. That, too, tends to slow their path to becoming mortgage-free.
Of course, everyone has their own story, and there are likely plenty of carreer-oriented homeowners in West Virginia. But, as statistical norms, there doesn’t seem to be any big mystery about why homeowners in some areas have fewer mortgages than in others.